TWSK Round 37 - Overhauling the System - Read 1st post

[SharesLoot]

Eh, I've actually considered Moose as a possibility. The fact he doesn't have much time would explain the short kills.

Yup. Besides, they are not really bad, just really short. Moose claims he isn't using his prepared kills – well, these probably were not prepared ones.
Before the re-roll, he was innocent, but that doesn't absolve him now. I'll vote for Moose, if only because I want to see if he is as invincible as he is starting to seem

By the way, Moose is the only one who hasn't even died once this round!



Bringing the ninjas together:

If it is Moose, we're all gonna feel really, really silly about all those missed lynches.

OPERATION:VOTEFORMOOSE IS GO.

Moose.......1...(knucklekraken)

Hmm... Five possibilities, who to choose. I've seen nothing thusfar that indicates anyone in particular, so...

KnuckleKraken.....1...(Dlover)

KnuckleKraken.....1...(Dlover)
Moose...............2...(knucklekraken, SharesLoot)

[Dlover]

You know what, I've had the suspicion for a while, so why not?

Moose...............3...(knucklekraken, SharesLoot, Dlover)

[davecom3]

Just to clarify things, I have to wonder whether the false witness role works as a warped scrying glass or if it works by randomly selecting a different person other than the killer to hone in on.

[Theonewhoisodd]

Just to clarify things, I have to wonder whether the false witness role works as a warped scrying glass or if it works by randomly selecting a different person other than the killer to hone in on.

I'll go ahead and answer this now, the false killer role works by me honing on one person when I have time and energy to figure it out, or I just choose random things when I just don't want to try or don't have time...

[askstoomuch]

well got to vote for someone if im not gulled already
Moose...............4...(knucklekraken, SharesLoot, Dlover, asks)

[SharesLoot]

well got to vote for someone if im not gulled already

It galls me that you do not know if someone culls you or gulls you

to gull: to dupe
to gall: to annoy
to cull: to remove

Once again, you made my day

[askstoomuch]

and thanks for expanding my knowloge of the english langauage i speak english 10 times a good as i did befor i found goblins

[SharesLoot]

and thanks for expanding my knowloge of the english langauage i speak english 10 times a good as i did befor i found goblins

I'm glad I never read your English tests before that, then. I might have commited suicide.

[askstoomuch]

well normaly i am better at it, most of the times i forget to reread what the hell im writing and just smash enter like a cavemen.
but since your people are so damm nice here ill try to put in a little more efford in my posts.

[SeeAMoose]

Eh, I've actually considered Moose as a possibility. The fact he doesn't have much time would explain the short kills.

I have stated a number of times that I always try to pre-write my kills, or at least the first three of them for a set. Currently I have two such sets, and no time to prepare any more than that. This is primarily because I'm completely insane and have decided to start a round of CTF in LSN's forum (come sign up ), in addition to writing a research paper/website on invasive species and programming KoreBot. If I were the killer you would see a sharp drop off in quality after kill 3, and my kills are all longer than this and better written. If you want to lynch me because I haven't died yet this round, fine, go right ahead. If you want to lynch me because you've failed to do so four times this round, you're welcome to. But if you actually think I'm the killer you're fooling yourselves. I will tell you right now that I am NOT the killer, but hey, maybe you guys will free up some time for me, and hell I've told you to lynch me the entire round. I guess I should be happy you're finally listening to me, I just wish you had done so sooner. I had kinda wanted to see if I could survive another tie, but that's up to you guys at this point. Oh... also, I bet you it's knuckle or Dlover.

Moose...............4...(knucklekraken, SharesLoot, Dlover, asks)
knucklekraken......1...(Moose)

[PicksUpSticks]

Hey guys sorry I didn't post this sooner... But I was the detective

That is all.

[Theonewhoisodd]

A mysterious figure walks in before stabbing at Picks' ghost and then throwing a mysterious box at him. He then leaves. The first person to PM me claiming this box gets it.

EDIT: The box has been claimed

[alopex]

We have two turns to catch the killer.

The hunting season of moose. Here in Finland it continues three more weeks. My clue hunting has been ineffective, so maybe I should join this nice bandwagon.

Although I still think it is more likely Knucklekraken. Especially when our detective voted him last turn.

Moose...............4...(knucklekraken, SharesLoot, Dlover, asks)
knucklekraken......2...(Moose, alopex)


I'll write my notes here, just in case if someone gets better idea from these (I have gotten only a headache):
- honk is written on forehead, heart, leg, throat.
- In three kills there is something in the middle or halfway (but not in the 2nd one).
- honk itself in its various combinations (K has always been a capital letter thus far...hmm).

[SeeAMoose]

Anyone want to at least give me a chance at a tie vote (to see if I can survive the roll yet again? ) Just to recap, the arguments for me being a killer are:
1) That I haven't died this round.
2) I don't have much time so I've been writing short kills (even though I have pre-written kills).
3) This:

Besides, they are not really bad, just really short. Moose claims he isn't using his prepared kills – well, these probably were not prepared ones.

Wait... run that by me again? So I have two prepared sets of kills, no time, and as a killer I'm not using my pre-prepared kills? Reading back over this a couple of times actually makes me a little suspicious of Shares, especially considering how she has been one of the people supporting my claim of innocence due to having a lot on my plate. The logic here just doesn't make sense, although the wreath is cool

Arguments against knuckle: HONK... he has a freaking goose in character

Again, lynch me if you want, but be prepared to be disappointed, I'm not the killer.

[SharesLoot]

Again, lynch me if you want, but be prepared to be disappointed, I'm not the killer.

I won't be once the time comes. I have a feeling that this is the last turn and we can finally go on to round 38. Moose, you will not make the killers win. Too much is at steak.

Yeah, I'm hungry

I've been talking to a Canadian all evening (at my company's christmas party) and he went on and on about how he likes home-made moose sausage

[SeeAMoose]

Okay... I'm convinced, Shares has a role, and is probably the killer. I base this on her drastic shift in position. If she were just a witness she would've changed more gradually... probably , but within a turn she went from saying that it isn't like my writing to saying that I'm the killer, based on logic that seems incredibly flawed coming from her (from other players not so much, but Shares has always been a great player and just seems to have a very logical mind). I suspect that there are a number of roles at play at the moment considering how few have died and how I turned a minor role box down because I felt even that would be too much extra work. I'm changing my vote to Shares, if any of you are smart and online you'll help me because I'm not the killer and the arguments against me are... well hell there don't seem to be any actual arguments against me, and it seems like these votes are only barely based on gut feelings. No one knows who to go after so people are guessing, it might help if people actually looked at others' behavior before voting.
Just to help illustrate the point, she went from the following:

To vote, or not to vote, that is the question.
Actually, this adapted quote lacks a "for Moose"
Nah, Moose still doesn't write like that if he has time, and I do believe he has kills prepared.

to this:

Eh, I've actually considered Moose as a possibility. The fact he doesn't have much time would explain the short kills.

Yup. Besides, they are not really bad, just really short. Moose claims he isn't using his prepared kills – well, these probably were not prepared ones.
Before the re-roll, he was innocent, but that doesn't absolve him now. I'll vote for Moose, if only because I want to see if he is as invincible as he is starting to seem

I don't mind being lynched normally... but it always annoys the hell out of me when I see people voting like this. That and I had kinda looked forward to a round where I avoided all attempts to kill me.

[Dlover]

Hmm... You are right, She has changed her point of view rather suddenly. Okay, I'll bite.

Moose...............3...(knucklekraken, SharesLoot, asks)
knucklekraken......1...(alopex)
SharesLoot..........2...(Moose, Dlover)

[SharesLoot]

Okay... I'm convinced, Shares has a role, and is probably the killer. I base this on her drastic shift in position. If she were just a witness she would've changed more gradually... probably , but within a turn she went from saying that it isn't like my writing to saying that I'm the killer, based on logic that seems incredibly flawed coming from her (from other players not so much, but Shares has always been a great player and just seems to have a very logical mind).
...

I don't mind being lynched normally... but it always annoys the hell out of me when I see people voting like this. That and I had kinda looked forward to a round where I avoided all attempts to kill me.

Aww, Moose, thanks for the compliments. At least those that you intended to be ones

Well, of course there was a shift. I was the detective and I knew with certainty that you were innocent. Then I was killed, lost my role, and a new killer was born

After my resurrection, I was still on a mission to save us from the Kitti. Once she died, everything was open again, and the new, short kills indicated someone pressed for time. Since the new role was assigned suddenly, and not all players are playing, I found it totally probable that even a Moose, who prepares kills beforehand and has little time, would be able to crank out something like that in 5 minutes. Besides, you seem to have a perfect alibi, which you repeat over and over. I am now very curious to see your bot in action, but I definitely don't believe a hard worker like you needs a break and relaxation once in a while. Maybe eat a sandwich, kill a goblin, post an excuse, and go back to work?

It's not illogical or a huge shift. You simply went from innocent to suspect, and I went from fake analysis heavily biased by my knowledge to true analysis strongly colored by my doubts and suspicions.

Make of that what you will. I am not the killer, but I have narrowed it down to 2 people. Maybe I have a role, but I am not at leisure to tell everyone. If you are cleared, then I definitely know who the killer is. Again, not me.

Hmm... You are right, She has changed her point of view rather suddenly. Okay, I'll bite.

Ouch, did you brush your teeth beforehand? Dog bites can be poisonous, and they always hurt like hell. I'm speaking from experience. I never was bitten by a lover of dogs, though. I hope it's less painful

On a more serious note, please read my explanation above and reconsider your vote change, Dlover. Thank you.

[knucklekraken]

Voting closes in, what, fifteen minutes?

[SharesLoot]

Voting closes in, what, fifteen minutes?

I'm excited. I really want to see if Moose is the killer. I bet 10 Gold and two cookies that he is! Any takers?

[SeeAMoose]

Make of that what you will. I am not the killer, but I have narrowed it down to 2 people. Maybe I have a role, but I am not at leisure to tell everyone. If you are cleared, then I definitely know who the killer is. Again, not me.

You do realize that you just painted a target on your chest, right? If the killer changes their kill to you, your knowledge will essentially be useless, that's assuming your knowledge is even accurate. Which unless you're the detective is far from certain. I am NOT the killer, but... you know what? I kinda hope they win so that kitti gets the credit she deserves for an awesome run as killer.

Oh I'm taking that bet right now. Can I have my gold and cookies now?

[knucklekraken]

I'm curious what was in that box.

[SeeAMoose]

Seriously, can I have my gold and cookies now? You were dead wrong Shares, I haven't told a single lie this round. I really did turn down a minor role box due to a lack of time, and I really wasn't the killer. I'd recommend lynching Shares... except I'm pretty sure the killers just won, you know what with there being a true love in this round, and given that there are only 4 players left team killer has as many people on it as team citizen. Either Shares or Knuckle (and quite possibly both) are probably on team killer.

*edit:* Moose shakes his head and starts laughing. I bet you Shares is the True Love, she said she had the list for killer narrowed down to two people but didn't do anything to hint at who that other person was, AND she said that she had a feeling that the round would end this turn.

[knucklekraken]

Why don't you refrain from posting in color until Odd kills you.

[SeeAMoose]

Kinda a foregone conclusion at this point, but sure, why not.